Closing your pool for the season is more than just draining and cleaning; the right pool cover is your final layer of protection. A quality cover keeps debris out, reduces algae growth, and protects your investment while your pool rests through the Minnesota winter.
Below, you’ll find a clear comparison of three popular options so you can choose the best fit for your needs.
1. Automatic Pool Covers
Best for: Year-round convenience, safety, and efficiency
Automatic or retractable covers work at the push of a button. They’re designed for everyday use, making it easy to keep your pool clean and safe.
Benefits:
- Blocks debris and sunlight to protect water quality
- Enhances safety by preventing accidental falls
- Reduces chemical and energy use
- Cuts down on long-term maintenance costs
- Retains heat for a more comfortable swim
- Long lifespan with proper care
Drawbacks:
- Higher upfront and replacement costs
- Professional installation required
- May need deck modifications on existing pools
- Can warm water more than some prefer
2. Mesh Pool Covers
Best for: Safety and durability in snowy climates
Mesh covers are strong enough to support thousands of pounds, making them a reliable choice for homes with kids or pets. They allow water from melted snow and ice to drain through, preventing heavy buildup.
Advantages:
- Lightweight and easy to handle
- Lets water pass through while blocking debris
- Long lifespan (12–15 years)
- Easy to remove and reinstall after the first setup
Disadvantages:
- More expensive than standard winter covers
- Requires tools and labor for installation
- Custom sizing can take weeks to order
Safety Note: The strength of a mesh cover means anyone who slips onto it stays above water, greatly reducing drowning risk.
3. Winter Pool Covers
Best for: Budget-friendly, short-term use
Winter covers act like a large tarp stretched over your pool, held in place by water bags or clips. Adding a pool pillow underneath can prevent sagging under snow and ice.
Pros:
- Affordable and widely available
- Simple to install
- Keeps sunlight from breaking down chlorine
Cons:
- Shorter lifespan
- Low durability compared to other covers
- Offers little to no safety protection
- Less visually appealing
Our Top Pick: Automatic Pool Covers
While each option has its place, we often recommend automatic covers for their unmatched convenience, safety, and energy savings.
Why homeowners love them:
- Effortless use – Cover or uncover your pool in under a minute.
- Cleaner water – Less debris means less maintenance.
- Peace of mind – An added layer of safety, especially for families.
- Energy efficiency – Helps retain heat and reduce filtration time, lowering energy costs.
Ready to Protect Your Pool This Winter?
Royal Pool & Spa installs and services all types of pool covers for homeowners in Minneapolis, St. Paul, and the surrounding Twin Cities area. Whether you want the convenience of an automatic cover or the durability of mesh, we’ll make sure your pool is ready for the cold months ahead.
To schedule your pool closing and cover installation today: